Greetings,
Enjoyed some ineresting flights at OddFellows, including three
different vintages of Penfolds Konunga Hills Shiraz Cab. 97, 98, and 01.
This week, we're invited to Kris/Eric's. As a "warm up", we're
going to Corner Table for Rhone Wines.
Our host, Scott Pampuch, would appreciate some feed back on
our dining experience. Perhaps you could add a line or two to
your wine notes on the food, ambiance, etc. I can forward same
to Scott next week.
6:30 p.m. at Corner Table.
Corner Table
4257 Nicollet Av S
Minneapolis 612-823-0011
Who:
Bob
Betsy
Lori
Nicolai
Jim/Louise
Ruth?
Find below a copy of the Kris/Eric Bojo Nuvo invite and
an article from the LA Times that recommends Cru Beaujolais
(Morgon, Fleurie, Brouilly, Moulin-a'-Vaent) and Alsatian
Pinot Gris with your Thanksgiving meal.
Cheers,
Jim
----- Forwarded message from "Jim L. Ellingson" <jellings(a)me.umn.edu>
-----
Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 10:35:02 -0600
From: "Jim L. Ellingson" <jellings(a)me.umn.edu>
To: wine(a)thebarn.com
Subject: [EFREEBURG(a)aol.com: Beaujolais Nouveau]
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.4i
As promised, here's the invite. Thanks to Eric and Kris for
the invite, and for hosting.
----- Forwarded message from EFREEBURG(a)aol.com -----
X-MessageWall-Score: 1 (
smtp-relay.enet.umn.edu)
Date: Tue, 09 Nov 2004 23:51:23 -0500
From: EFREEBURG(a)aol.com
To: cfberge(a)earthlink.net,
angela_heffernan_2000(a)yahoo.com, jhegstrom(a)csom.umn.edu,
jellings(a)me.umn.edu, Kris(a)france44.com, KrisIgo(a)aol.com,
Georgeanna(a)earthlink.net, amaza.a.reitmeier(a)medtronic.com,
Cc: dmoskowitz(a)citypages.com, naomirettke(a)hotmail.com,
Subject: Beaujolais Nouveau
X-Mailer: Atlas Mailer 2.0
X-AOL-IP: 65.25.251.114
X-AOL-Language: english
Garagista Beaujolais Nouveau
Celebrate the new harvest at the Igo/Freeburg residence
Thursday November 18th - 7 PM until pretty late
South Minneapolis
4204 10th Ave. South
10th is just two blocks east of Chicago Ave
Please bring a bottle of wine to be opened- French would be appropriate, Beaujolais
Nouveau would be perfect. ? Anything will work really. ? Feel free to bring friends. ?
RSVP appreciated but not required.
Simple food will be provided- lots of fresh baguette, really good butter, ham, mustard,
hard-boiled eggs, cheese, olives and a bit of chocolate from our dear friend Suzy. ?
The party will be in our wood stove heated garage- dress warmly and wear your beret.
Questions/Directions/RSVP- ?Eric 612-220-6693
We're looking forward to seeing you. ?
----- End forwarded message -----
latimes.com
http://www.latimes.com/features/food/la-fo-wine17nov17,1,5547635.story?coll…
THANKSGIVING | WINES THAT WORK
Congeniality by the bottle
A tasting finds easygoing wines for the meal's crazy array of flavors.
By Leslie Brenner
Times Staff Writer
November 17, 2004
It's the eternal question: What to drink with Thanksgiving dinner?
Every year, the pundits of wine-and-turkey-matching put forth their picks: Zinfandel, they
suggest perkily; after all, it's a native American grape. Or Riesling: A safe bet,
since it's generally food friendly and tends to work with sweet and spicy dishes. Or
Beaujolais Nouveau . very Thanksgiving-y, since the new vintage is released virtually on
the eve of the holiday. Or Pinot Noir . that, conventional wisdom dictates, goes with
everything.
But is there a wine writer between Lodi and the Finger Lakes who has actually tasted, in a
focused way, a whole slew of different wines with an actual Thanksgiving dinner? Or are
they just, well, guessing?
Two weeks ago, our tasting panel sat down to a real, nontheoretical, lavish Thanksgiving
meal, prepared by the Times Test Kitchen using the recipes from chefs featured in this
issue. Our aim was to sample a wide range of wines and find out what works best with the
cacophony of wonderful flavors that is the Thanksgiving plate.
From the rich turkey to the spiced sweet potato pur�e,
from the earthy collard greens with bacon and lentils to the tangy bread salad with dried
cranberries, arugula and pecans, the range of flavors, textures, sweetness and acid is all
over the map . as it always is this holiday.
The potato gratin layered with wild mushrooms is luxurious; you could drink that with a
white Burgundy or a serious red Bordeaux and be very happy. But take a bite of cranberry
jelly, and your palate would go haywire as the wine short-circuits.
We left out the appetizers and the dessert from this experiment, figuring that if we could
find a table wine (or two or five) that worked with the main plate, we'd be in fat
city. But we can say with confidence that Thomas Keller's salmon rillettes and shrimp
and avocado bites are an easy match: Champagne. Or an un-oaked Sauvignon Blanc such as
Sancerre. Or a lightly oaked California Sauvignon Blanc.
For dessert, a tawny Port would be heavenly with Sherry Yard's multi-tiered pumpkin
torte; or skip the wine with it, and have a glass of Bourbon or Scotch or Armagnac
afterward.
The ultimate test
To find the ideal Thanksgiving wine, we gathered 27 wines from around the world. They
included 13 grape varieties from nine regions and were priced from $9.50 to $27. We set
the table with glasses . lots of them . and place settings. Times Test Kitchen Director
Donna Deane and her staff cooked up a storm and arranged the Thanksgiving buffet. We
filled our plates and sat down. We tasted.
Going into the project, the panel, which included columnists Russ Parsons and David Shaw,
restaurant critic S. Irene Virbila, staff writer Corie Brown and assistant editor Laurie
Winer, all expressed personal preferences for red wine with Thanksgiving dinner. Yet all
of us were amazed at how well some of the white wines worked with the range of flavors on
the plate.
We were particularly wowed by Pinot Gris from Alsace (also known as Tokay Pinot Gris).
These wines tended to have enough assertive aromas and flavors to stand up to the rich,
salty and sweet food, and enough supple texture to be substantial with the food, smoothing
the transitions. And one panelist put it, "Their refreshing acidity clears your
palate for every next bite."
A 2001 Domaine Bott-Geyl Pinot Gris Beblenheim, $16, and a 1999 Rolly Gassman Tokay Pinot
Gris Rotielbel de Rorschwihr, $22, were just the ticket. They worked so harmoniously with
the foods that we guessed that other Alsace Pinot Gris would also be great matches.
A Vouvray from the Loire Valley paired similarly well. On the other hand, a white Rh�ne
blend and a blend of Chardonnay and white Rh�ne varieties, both from Paso Robles, fell
flat with the flavors on the plate: The wine did nothing for the food, and the food did
nothing for the wine.
A white Anjou was delicious on its own, but its delicate aromas and flavors were
overwhelmed by the gratin and the Savoy cabbage. A bone-dry Riesling from Germany's
Pflaz region was an acceptable match, but its austerity prevented it from wowing anyone as
a match with the table's assertive tastes.
When it came to reds, there were a few surprises.
The American Pinot Noirs we tasted . a 2002 Hartford, $22, from the Sonoma Coast and a
Witness Tree, $19, from Oregon's Willamette Valley . didn't work at all with the
food: The wines were too thick in texture, coating the tongue.
It's possible, we agreed, there might be some American Pinots that would have the
appropriate fruit and wouldn't be too heavy for the meal. But if there are,
they'd likely be at a price point that most people wouldn't want to approach for
a large Thanksgiving party.
Contrary to an oft-stated belief, Zinfandel, with its high alcohol level, was a total
disaster with the food. (We sampled two . a 2001 Franus from Brandlin Vineyard in Mount
Veeder, $17, and a 2002 Palm Cellars, $22, from Paso Robles.) With the richness of the
food, even a few sips of it were a drag on the palate.
We agreed that what we needed was a red that drinks easily, has plenty of fruit, yet
isn't super concentrated; it shouldn't fight with the food. It should be fairly
young and have a generous bouquet.
This is not the moment to bring out your showpiece wines, for any delicacy will likely get
lost in the smorgasbord of flavors.
Our 'aha!' moment
The panel agreed that the most successful and dependable wines for the meal were
Beaujolais crus. These are the light reds (from a subregion of southern Burgundy) that are
named for the villages . or crus . where their grapes are grown.
Two 2003 Beaujolais crus, a Fleurie and a Morgon, at $18 each, were the stars of the
tasting.
They were delicious and drinkable, with pretty cherry and plummy aromas and delicious red
fruit flavors that harmonized nicely with all of the flavors on the plate, including the
dried cranberries in the bread salad.
They had enough bright acid to stand up to the salad's vinaigrette, as well as to cut
through the richness of the turkey and the potato gratin. Also, they were both refreshing
and earthy enough to work with the salty bacon in the collard greens and the rich
sweetness of the sweet potato pur�e.
We also tasted a $12 wine with a Beaujolais-Villages appellation, a 2003 Tr�nel Fils.
While it didn't clash with anything, it didn't have the character to stand up to
the plate the way the Beaujolais crus did.
Another category that paired nicely was village wine from the Rh�ne Valley, three wines
from Saint-Joseph in particular (a 2001 J.L. Chave and a 2000 Bernard Faurie, both $27,
and a 2001 Domaine Richard old-vines Les Nuelles, $18). Though we didn't taste a
Gigondas, which we also imagined might work, a terrific $10 non-vintage red table wine
from noted Gigondas producer Louis Barruol, labeled "Little James Basket Press,"
was good, but didn't sing with the table's flavors as did the Saint-Joseph
A dependable $9.50 C�tes du Rh�ne from E. Guigal came off as a little thin with the food.
It came as no surprise that a red from the Loire Valley would get along nicely; these
Cabernet Francs are always food-friendly. A 2002 Olga Raffault Chinon "La
Poplini�re," $17, had plenty of fruit and a supple texture that was marvelous with
just about everything on the plate.
And modern Riojas, with their vibrant fruit and soft tannins, are another good choice . a
2001 Propriedad H. Remondo, $25, was a delicious companion.
A number of us had thought that a couple of wines from Italy's Piedmont region would
be felicitous Thanksgiving wines: Dolcetto and Barbera. We were wrong. Although they were
terrific on their own, their flavor profile wasn't right with the food; they fell
flat.
Since we were so excited by the congeniality of the Beaujolais crus, we planned a second
tasting of an assortment . a focused, blind tasting without food . in order to give
specific recommendations. (See sidebar.)
It would be wonderful, we thought, to have a bunch of different Beaujolais crus . a
Morgon, a Fleurie, a Moulin-�-Vent, a Brouilly . for the Thanksgiving table.
If you want other stories on this topic, search the Archives at
latimes.com/archives.
--
------------------------------ *
* Dr. James Lee Ellingson, Adjunct Professor jellings(a)me.umn.edu *
* University of Minnesota, tel: 651/645-0753 fax 651 XXX XXXX *
* Great Lakes Brewing News, 1569 Laurel Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 *