FYI/FYA (anxiety).
October 1, 2007
Citigroup Warns of 60% Earnings Drop
By ERIC DASH and JULIA WERDIGIER
Citigroup issued a profit warning today, estimating a 60 percent drop in third-quarter
earnings because of write-downs for securities backed by subprime mortgages and loans tied
to corporate takeovers.
Separately, UBS, Europe.s biggest bank, predicted an unexpected loss in the third quarter
because of a $3.42 billion write-down for the value of mortgage-backed securities and
announced a management shake-up.
Citigroup said it expects its third-quarter net income to fall to $2.2 billion from $5.51
billion in the period a year earlier as it books losses on loans related to leveraged
buyouts, weak fixed-income trading results and the deterioration of complex
mortgage-backed securities that contained bad subprime loans. It also said its consumer
business would be hurt by higher credit costs.
.Our expected third-quarter results are a clear disappointment,. Charles Prince, the chief
executive of Citigroup, said in a statement. .The decline in income was driven primarily
by weak performance in fixed-income credit market activities, write-downs in leveraged
loan commitments, and increases in consumer credit costs..
.We expect to return to a normal earnings environment in the fourth quarter,. Mr. Prince
added.
Mr. Prince faces mounting pressure from investors because of Citigroup.s sluggish stock
price. Today.s announcement, in fact, comes four years since Mr. Prince took over as chief
executive from Sanford I. Weill. Its stock price was in the $47 to $49 range in October
2003. This morning it was trading at $46.21 after slumping about 1 percent on the profit
warning.
Citigroup took the unusual step of moving its third-quarter earnings release to the
morning of Oct. 15 from Oct. 19.
Citigroup.s warning comes as other Wall Street firms have hinted they will face serious
profit declines. Last month, Merrill Lynch warned that its third-quarter results would
suffer, and Bank of America.s financial chief said the turbulent markets would have a
.meaningful impact. on third-quarter results. J. P. Morgan Chase has not publicly
commented on its third-quarter results, but executives there have acknowledged tougher
market conditions, which will likely have an effect.
So far, Wall Street investment houses that have announced their third-quarter results have
run the gamut. Goldman Sachs powered through the turmoil in the credit markets to post a
79 percent increase in profit, its third-best quarter ever. At Bear Stearns, earnings fell
61 percent on sharp losses related to its hedge funds and exposure to subprime
investments. Third-quarter profit was down 3 percent at Lehman Brothers and 7 percent at
Morgan Stanley, but the performance at both companies was stronger than expected.
Citigroup said it expects to take a $1.9 billion pretax loss related to its fixed-income
capital markets activities, which have been a cornerstone of its business ever since it
absorbed Salomon Brothers. About $1.3 billion of those losses are related to the
deterioration of mortgage-related securities, including collateralized debt obligations
and other financial instruments containing bad subprime loans. It will also record a loss
of $600 million in trading because of .significant market volatility and the disruption of
the historical pricing relationships..
The company also said it expects to write down about $1.4 billion of funded and unfunded
leveraged loans that have fallen in value. These commitments totaled $69 billion at the
end of the second quarter and $57 billion at the end of the third quarter.
Citigroup also expects a $2.6 billion pretax rise in credit costs in its consumer
businesses. About $1.95 billion, or three-fourths of the increase, is from money set aside
to cover future loan losses. The remaining $650 million is from higher net credit losses
in the quarter.
Citigroup, which has long championed that its diversity of activities could partly offset
poor results, said other parts of its business performed well.
At UBS, the bank said it plans to cut 1,500 jobs and that Clive Standish, its chief
financial officer, and Huw Jenkins, the head of its investment bank, are stepping down.
The Zurich-based bank said its pretax loss for the three months through September was 600
million to 800 million Swiss francs.
The shares slumped as much as 4.3 percent in early trading on Monday in Zurich after the
loss surprised analysts, who had expected the bank to remain profitable. The Credit Suisse
Group reported a profit today even though earnings were hurt by the recent credit market
slump.
Marcel Rohner, who took over as chief executive of UBS in July after his predecessor was
ousted over losses at the bank.s in-house hedge fund, called the loss .unsatisfactory. and
in order to .be as transparent as possible. he has taken .decisive action. and made
appropriate senior management changes.
As part of the management changes, Mr. Rohner will take on the role of chairman and chief
executive of the investment bank and Marco Suter, the bank.s executive vice chairman, will
become chief financial officer. Walter Stuerzinger, the bank.s chief risk officer, will
become chief operating officer. UBS will report full third-quarter results on Oct. 30.
UBS shares fell 1 franc, or 1.6 percent, to 61.6 francs in early trading in Zurich. The
shares have fallen 17 percent this year compared with 10 percent at Credit Suisse.
The loss, UBS.s first in a quarter since 1998 when it had to write down its investment in
Long-Term Capital Management, may raise concerns among investors that other lenders with
large investment banking operations suffered similar losses on the back of collapsing
prices for securities backed by mortgages and other high-risk debt investments following
the subprime mortgage crisis in the United States this summer.
Lehman Brothers and Goldman Sachs already reduced the value of some of their fixed-income
investments while still reporting better-than-expected quarterly earnings last month. But
their reporting period includes June, the month before the market downturn began, and some
analysts have warned that earnings of banks whose third quarter excludes the profitable
month of June may be hit harder.
Yet, investors may not get to know the full fallout of the market crisis until early next
year as finance chiefs and accountants are working through large portfolios with extremely
complex and often illiquid investment vehicles that are difficult to value correctly in
times of volatile markets.
--
------------------------------ *
* Dr. James Ellingson, jellings(a)me.umn.edu *
* University of Minnesota, tel: 651/645-0753 *
* Great Lakes Brewing News, 1569 Laurel Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 *